ZRP
Tuca Zbarcea & Asociatii

Landmark ECJ ruling on a Romanian case involving deduction of VAT on abandoned investments

17 Noiembrie 2020   |   CMS Romania

For more information on this ECJ ruling, contact CMS experts Roxana Popel, Andrei Tercu and Ramona Tudor.

 
 
On 12 November, the ECJ issued its decision in case C-734/19 ITH Comercial Timisoara SRL (ITH) involving the input VAT recovery for goods and services no longer used by the taxpayer (i.e. pertaining to abandoned real-estate projects).

The Court ruled that the right to deduct input VAT on goods and services acquired with a view to carrying out taxable operations is maintained when the investment projects initially planned have been abandoned due to circumstances beyond the control of the taxable person.

The situation that gave rise to the main proceedings was the applicant’s failure to complete two building projects, which it had begun in 2006 and 2007 in accordance with agreements with a company manufacturing lifts and escalators.


In subsequent periods, the company incurred expenditures in connection with various preparatory steps (for which input VAT was deducted), such as applying for a building permit and concluding various technical consultancy agreements. Due to the background of the economic crisis, the projects were put on hold during 2008 and finally written-off in 2015 financial statements.

Romanian tax authorities assessed additional VAT on the two building projects and based their judgement on the grounds that ITH was aware since the launch of the first project of elements that might lead to its non-completion, in so far as a local urban plan had already been approved and that ITH had assumed the risks arising from not having its project included in this plan.

Unsurprisingly, the Court's ruling that the right to deduct input VAT on goods (in this case on real estate assets) and services acquired with a view to carrying out taxable operations is maintained when the investment projects initially planned have been abandoned due to circumstances beyond the control of the taxable person means that there is no need to adjust this VAT if the taxable person still intends to use the goods for a taxable activity.

The takeaway in our view is that the Court once again stated that it is not for tax authorities to assess the merits of the reasons compelling a taxable person to abandon the economic activity originally envisaged. The court did not accept the argument that ITH knew there was a risk of non-approval by a public authority for a necessary zonal urban plan and that it did not constitute “circumstances beyond the control of the taxable person”.

As this case shows, there are still situations where the Romanian tax authorities question the reasons behind the abandonment decision, irrespective of the taxpayer showing proof that actions were taken towards completing the investment. We hope that this judgement will limit such assessments.

For more information on this ECJ ruling, contact CMS experts Roxana Popel, Andrei Tercu and Ramona Tudor.
 
 

PNSA

 
 

ARTICOLE PE ACEEASI TEMA

ARTICOLE DE ACELASI AUTOR


 

Ascunde Reclama
 
 

POSTEAZA UN COMENTARIU


Nume *
Email (nu va fi publicat) *
Comentariu *
Cod de securitate*







* campuri obligatorii


Articol 358 / 3235
 

Ascunde Reclama
 
BREAKING NEWS
ESENTIAL
LegiTeam: Radu și Asociații SPRL recrutează avocați stagiari pentru practica de consultanță
Avocații Mușat & Asociații întrevăd o creștere spectaculoasă a proiectelor de energie, dacă statul se va concentra pe câteva direcții strategice. Iulian Popescu, Deputy Managing Partner: În ultimii ani am observat o recurență crescută a mandatelor din partea firmelor internaționale care, deși au prezență în România, preferă să lucreze cu departamentele noastre specializate
LegiTeam: Bondoc si Asociatii is looking for a Real Estate lawyer
Studiu realizat de DLA Piper | Amenzi în valoare de 272,5 mil. E aplicate de autoritățile europene de reglementare a protecției datelor în baza RGPD. Romania a aplicat amenzi în valoare totală peste 650.000 Euro
Sistemul de sănătate și-a dezvăluit anul trecut mai multe vulnerabilităţi care pot fi reglementate şi combătute. Cele mai mari probleme cu care s-au confruntat jucătorii din sectorul Healthcare & Pharma și provocările anului 2021, analizate de Livia Zamfiropol și Alina Lăcătuș, Parteneri DLA Piper România
Debutul anului 2021 aduce schimbări majore în sectorul energetic. Noutățile, explicate de avocații Maravela Popescu & Asociații | Mihaela Nyerges, Managing Associate: Am sesizat un interes crescut pentru proiectele de producere a energiei regenerabile; țara noastră redevine o destinație atractivă pentru investiții în acest sector
CMS România îl promovează pe Andrei Tercu în poziția de Tax Director
In-houseLegal.ro | Cum s-au adaptat marile companii private la ‘noua normalitate’ și ce sprijin oferă echipele de Legal în perioada pandemiei. Simona Vasiliu: Paradoxal, desfășurarea activității „la distanță” a menținut și chiar a crescut performanța echipei
LegiTeam | WOLF THEISS recrutează pentru echipa locală de Litigii și Arbitraj
LegiTeam: POPESCU & ASOCIAŢII is expanding its team, looking for SENIOR ATTORNEYS to join the firm’s DISPUTE RESOLUTION practice.
Refinitiv Legal Advisers - Full Year 2020 | Piața globală de M&A a pierdut doar 5% anul trecut, iar piața europeană a crescut cu 36% în pandemie. Mai multe firme cu prezență la București au intrat în Top 25 global, european și regional
Mușat & Asociații cooptează 3 noi parteneri equity și promovează alți 7 în poziții de senioritate în firmă
 
Citeste pe SeeNews Digital Network
  • BizBanker

  • BizLeader

      in curand...
  • SeeNews

    in curand...